國內外皆以推動設立地質公園為相關景點的永續發展方向，但是卻缺乏可以實際操作的理論與工具來確保地景朝向永續經營，尤其是對於易觸型地景而言，更應考量運用相關指標來進行管理。因此本文以理念相似但發展較為成熟的生態旅遊相關指標為基礎，補強人為壓力對地景的影響等向度，來建構易觸型地景之永續發展指標系統。不過目前仍缺乏人為活動對易觸型地景之衝擊等實證研究，因此本研究同時進行相關探討。本文並以野柳地質公園進行個案研究，除了協助該地區進一步釐清永續發展之議題外，也整合個案評估過程以及指標建立過程，提出易觸型地景之永續發展評估程序。
本研究永續指標初步指標系統以易觸型地景之特性為基礎，並參酌生態旅遊地評估架構來建立，之後透過德爾菲法及層級分析法獲致學者、官員、志工、居民及業者等32位專家之共識以決定最終系統與權重。系統共含三個層級，包括3個子系統、13個評估構面及61項指標。各子系統權重最高為「地景資源與觀光的關係(47.8)」，其次為「社區與地景資源的關係(33.7)」及「觀光與社區的關係(18.5)」；最高權重評估構面則為「地景遊憩承載壓力(15)」，此結果說明了地質公園在永續發展中最需考量的面向與重心，也符合世界地質公園的發展準則。
人為壓力對地景影響之部分，分別透過長時間尺度與短時間尺度來探討。長時間尺度之探討為透過比對已知年代岩石外表形貌與現況的差距推估，發現女王頭頸部平均後退速率約為每年2.3mm~2.5mm之間。短期後退速率則以實驗設計的方式將女王頭與對照組(自然營力)做後退速率比較，岩石樣點之速率測量則透過比對適當時間間隔的微觀尺度照片，並計算期間崩落砂粒數目；結果透過成對樣本t檢定發現女王頭樣點速率皆顯著大於對照組，這個速率的差異可以推論就是人為壓力所造成。
實地評估部分則將建構完成之指標系統與人為壓力評估結果交由各權益關係人，針對相關指標項目進行評估。整個指標系統將設計成地景資源(專家及管理人員)、社區(居民)及觀光(遊客)等三份涵蓋不同指標項目之問卷，地景資源問卷中並附加人為壓力對地景影響等摘要報告。評估結果顯示野柳地質公園整體加權評值為46.65分，屬於「潛在不永續發展」之狀態，進一步透過AMOEBA模型來檢視，最需加強的是「地景遊憩承載壓力」與「管理單位與社區的互動關係」兩個評估構面，權重達成百分比各只有29.6%與33.0%，已接近不永續發展的狀態，因此另外引用學者之理論來對管理者提供適當管理規劃之建議。
本研究並整合評估程序提出易觸型地景之永續評估8項步驟，研究成果提供了一套適當的管理工具，可供野柳及相關地質地形景點永續管理規劃上之參考。

Although UNESCO(United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) advocates the importance of sustainable Geopark development, few researches have referred practical implementation methodologies for sustainability assessment. Especially for accessible landscape areas, like Yehliu Geopark, we should use indicators to monitor the environmental change of landscape to avoid any unrecoverable damage. Based on the sustainable assessment construct of an ecotourism site, we built a preliminary indicator system for accessible landscape areas. Then we used Delphi technique to identify evaluation indicators, and used Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP)to decide the weights of indicators. With respect to the sustainable content of this geological site, we set recession rates of the rock surface to be parts of the indicator system. Results show a hierarchical system which includes 3 subsystems, 13 dimensions, and 61 indicators. Among the 3 subsystems, “the relationship between Geopark and tourism” has the highest weight. “The relationship between locals and Geopark”, and “the relationship between tourism and locals” follow it. These results are compatible with the principle of sustainable development – that tourism development should be based on the sustainable utilization of resource.”
For the indicators of rock surface recession rates, the Pedestal Rocks in Yehliu were influenced by visitors’ behavior for a long time. However, few researches referred it. This study attempts to estimate the recession rate and measure the antropogeneous effect on the rock surface. In respect of long-period scale, we compared known age rock surface with present shape, we find out the recession rate of the Queen Head’s neck is 2.3mm~2.5mm/yr. As for the short-period scale, recession rates were determined for each time interval by comparison of 1.0 cm2 regions of the most recent microphotographs with the previous time’s image, and counting the disappearance of individual grains in a specific time interval to obtain the linear surface recession rate. Furthermore, this study utilized experiment design to compare the recession rates between two pedestal rocks, Queen Head and the control one. Results show the recession rates of Queen Head are faster than the control one, especially in the neck of Queen Head’s north side. It might be attributed to the antropogeneous effect. After result shows the recession rate of the Queen Head is faster than any published data. It might imply that there is a notable antropegeneous effect on the rock surface.
Then the study performs a case study to illustrate the application and the utility of the indicator system. We measured Yehliu Geopark holistic by 3 subsystems, 13 dimensions, and 61 indicators. Local residents, tourists, experts, and resource administration were interviewed to evaluate the status of indicators. And we supplied quantitative information for main environmental indicators in the questionaire. Next we calculated the weighted scores of total system, subsystems, dimensions, and indicators to understand the sustainability of this site. Results show Yehliu Geopark is classified into the level of potential unsustainable. Besides, we use AMOEBA models to illustrate the system quality. We find two dimensions, “ Carrying capacity of landscape” and “The relationship between administration and local residents ” that need to be improved more urgently. Finally, this research provide an assessment procedure for sustainable accessible landscape area management. The study provides a valuable tool for sustainable destination management and the indicator system can be reapplied to other destinations.

參考文獻
《中文部分》
王鑫(1997)，地景保育，台北：明文書局，10-12。
王鑫(2001)，野柳的地質之旅，國際海岸地景保育與經營研討會論文集，17-28。
王鑫，李桂華(1984)台灣北海岸野柳擎柱石成因之研究，經濟部中央地質調查所特刊，3：257-272。
王鑫(2003)，地質公園的設置與推動(上)，地景保育通訊，19: 2-9。
左顯能(2000)，觀光地區規劃永續發展之研究-以東北角海岸風景特定區為例，博士論文，台灣大學地理研究所。
吳水泉(2001)，企業發展策略之共識度研究，私立中原大學企業管理研究所未出版之碩士論文，53。
交通部觀光局(1985)，風景特定區管理規則，台北。
李光中、王鑫(2004)，建立和評估自然保護區社區參與論壇之研究—以櫻花鉤吻鮭野生動物保護區為例，地理學報，36: 1-22。
李桂華(1984)，台灣北部野柳風景區擎柱石景物之研究，台灣大學地理研究所未出版之碩士論文。
李公哲(1998)，永續指標，環境工程會刊，9(4): 24-35。
何春蓀(1990)，普通地質學，台北：五南圖書，125-150。
於幼華、張益誠(1999)，永續發展指標，環境教育季刊，37: 53-74。
宋秉明(2000)，永續觀光發展的原則與方向，第一屆觀光、休閒、遊憩、餐旅學術研討會會議論文集，中國文化大學，台北，1-11。
林俊全(2006)，野柳地質公園推動，台北：交通部觀光局北海岸及觀音山國家風景特定區管理處。
林裕強(2002)，永續觀光發展指標之建立-從認知觀點，碩士論文，中國文化大學觀光事業研究所。
林雪美、林裕強(2006)，遊客行為對野柳女王頭風化速率的影響，第十屆臺灣地理國際學術研討會論文集。
林裕強、林雪美(2007)，野柳蕈狀岩風化速率之研究，台灣地球科學聯合學術研討會，台北：中華民國地球科學學會。
林明璋(2007)，近景攝影測量應用於泥岩區地形測繪之研究。2007年全球華人地理學家大會論文集，388-392，台北：中國地理學會。
林素貞(1986)，德爾菲技巧應用於垃圾掩埋廠址之評估體系建立與權重分配，中國土木水利工程學會75年年會論文集，中國土木水利工程學會編，台北：中國土木水利工程學會。
林全洲(2003年5月4日)，女王頭也快斷頸，聯合晚報，4版，話題新聞。
林俊全(1996)，野柳的女王頭多老了？地景保育通訊，4: 1-2。
邱瑞杰(2005年2月2日)，野柳擺咖啡座？ 漁港：阮不愛，聯合報，C2版，北縣要聞。
施照輝(2005)，野柳地質公園的轉型紀要與發展方向，地景保育通訊，23: 5-11。
郭乃文(2000)，台灣地區非都市土地環境管理與永續發展:以國家公園規劃與經營，博士論文，台灣大學環境工程研究所。
秦中、張捷、彭學藝、王興山(2005)，四川樂山大佛風化的初步探討，地理研究，24(6): 928-934。
曹正偉(1995)，遊憩對景觀之衝擊，碩士論文，台灣大學地理研究所。
曹勝雄、林裕強(2002)，永續觀光指標之建立，2002生態旅遊學術論文發表會論文集。
陳汝勤、莊文星(1992)，第七章 沉積物之組織與構造，岩石學。台北：聯經出版社，184-186。
陳建佑(2004)，地理學者對環境永續指標權重計算之探討—AHP法之應用，碩士論文，彰化師範大學地理學系。
許俊偉(2006年3月7日)，守護凋零女王頭蕭老廿七年不悔，中國時報，A8版，社會脈動。
唐研理(1999)，德爾菲法應用於廠址評選之研究-以花蓮縣北區垃圾焚化廠為例，碩士論文，東華大學自然資源管理研究所。
張紹勳(2007)，研究方法，台中：滄海書局。
黃有傑、羅紹麟(2005)，台灣森林生態系經營社會經濟之準則與指標建構，中華林學季刊，38(2): 245-254。
黃慶安(2003年6月22日)，搶救女王頭 寶貝野柳，民生報，B6版，戶外旅遊。
楊迪文(2002年9月17日)，野柳火警 疑人為縱火，聯合報，18版，台北縣新聞。
蕭玉華(2004)，國際會議地點選址評估模式之研究—Fuzzy AHP之應用，碩士論文，南華大學旅遊事業管理學研究所。
歐聖榮(1997)，台灣潛在生態觀光及冒險旅遊產品研究與調查，台北：交通部觀光局，79-87。
劉正輝(2007)，試論自然遺產與文化遺產整合保護體系之建構-以台灣世界遺產潛力點為例，海峽兩岸世界遺產規劃與管理機制研討會論文集，台北：行政院文化建設委員會，9-22。
趙信甫(2003)，地質公園的評鑑與認證，地景保育通訊，19: 13-18。
鄧振源、曾國雄(1989a)，層級分析法(AHP)的內涵特性與應用(上)，中國統計學報，27(6): 5-23。
鄧振源、曾國雄(1989b)，層級分析法(AHP)的內涵特性與應用(下)，中國統計學報，27(7): 1-20。
鄭允文，薛達元，張更生(1994)，我國自然保護區生態評價指標和評價標準，農村生態環境，3: 1-5。
鄭滄濱(2001)，軟體組織提升人員能力之成熟度模糊評估模式，碩士論文，台灣科技大學資訊管理研究所。
盧道杰(2004)，台灣社區保育的發展-近年來國內三個個案的分析，地理學報，(37)，1-25。

《外文部分》
Bottrill, C., & Pearce, D.(1995). Ecotourism: Towards a key elements approach to operationalising the concept. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 3(1): 45-54.
Cater, E.(1994). Ecotourism in the third world problems and prospects for sustainability. In E. Cater, & G. Lowman(Eds.), Ecotourism: A sustainable option?(pp.69-86), Chichester, United Kingdom: Wiley.
Ceballos-Lascurain, H.(1996). Tourism, ecotourism and protected areas. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.
Clayton, A. M. H., & Redcliffe, N. J.(1996). Sustainability: A systems approach. London: Earthscan.
Coccossis, H., & Mexa, A.(2002). Defining, measuring and evaluating carrying capacity in European tourism destination. Athens, Greece: Environmental Planning Laboratory of the University of the Aegean.
Cooke, R.U., & Gibbs, G. B.(1994). Crumbling heritage? Studies of stone weathering in polluted atmospheres. Atmosphere Environment, 28(7): 1355~1456.
Eder, W.(1999). Geoparks for the future, Earth Heritage, 12. English Nature.
Froede, Jr.C.R., & Akridge, A.J.(2003). Isolated areas of pulpit rocks on the Lookout Mountain synclinal ridge: possible origin and development. Southeastern Geology, 41(4): 225–228.
Goodal, B., & Stabler, M. J.(1997). Principles influencing the determination of environmental standards for sustainable tourism. In M. J. Stabler(Ed.), Tourism and sustainability: Principles and practices(pp. 279–304). Oxon: Cab Internaitonal.
Goudie, A.S., & Viles, H.(1997). Salt Weathering Hazards, p.235. Wiley and Sons.
Green, H., Hunter, C., & Moore, B.(1990). Assessing the environmental impact of tourism development: Using the Delphi technique. Tourism Management, 11(2): 111-120.
Hall, K.,(1997). Rock temperatures and implications for cold region weathering. New data from Viking Valley, Alexander Island, Antarctica. Permafrost and Periglacial Process, 8: 69–90.
Halsey, D.P., Mitchell, D.J., & Dews, S.J.(1998). Influence of climatically induced cycles in physical weathering. Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology, 31: 359 – 367.
Hughes, P.(1994). Planning for Sustainable Tourism: The ECOMOST Project. Lewes, East Sussex: International Federation of Tour Operators.
Hughes, G.(2002). Environmental Indicators. Annals of Tourism Research, 29(2): 457-477.
Hwang, C. L., & Lin, M. J.(1987). Group decision making under multiple criteria. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
Johnson, J. D. & Snepenger, D. J.(1993). Application of the tourism life cycle concept in the greater Yellowstone Region. Society and Natural Resources, 6(2): 127–148.
Ko, T. G.(2005). Development of a tourism sustainability assessment procedure: a conceptual approach. Tourism Management, 26: 431-445.
Kreisel, W. E.(1984). Representation of the environmental quality profile of a metropolitan area. Environmental Monitoring & Assessment, 4(1), 15-33.
Kutay, K.(1989). The New Ethic in Adventure Travel. The Environmental Journal, 12：468-475.
Lewin, S.Z.(1990). The susceptibility of calcareous stones to salt decay. In: Zezza, F.(Ed.), The Conservation of Monuments in the Mediterranean Basin. Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium, Venice, 59– 63.
Lee, M.R. & Parsons, I.(1999). Biomechanical and biochemical weathering of lichen- encrusted granite: textural controls on organic–mineral interactions and deposition of silica-rich layers. Chemical Geology, 161: 385– 397.
Li, W.(2004). Environmental management indicators for ecotourism in China’s nature reserves: a case study in Tianmushan Nature Reserve. Tourism Management, 25(5): 559–564.
Linston, H. A., & Turoff, M.(1978). The Delphi method, techniques and applications. Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley.
Mayer, L.(1992). Some comments on equilibrium concepts and geomorphic systems. Geomorphology, 5: 277– 295.
McGreevy, J.P.(1985). Thermal properties as controls on rock surface temperature maxima, and possible implications for rock weathering. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 10: 125 – 136.
Meierding, T.C.(1993). Inscription legibility method for estimating rock weathering rates. Geomorphology, 6: 273 – 286.
Miller, G.(2001). The Development of indicators for sustainable tourism: Results of a Delphi survey of tourism researchers. Tourism Management, 22(4): 351-362.
More, T. & Stevens, T.(2000). Do user fees exclude low-income people from resource-based recreation? Journal of Leisure Research, 32(3): 341-357.
Norton, B.(1987). Why preserve natural variety? Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University.
Orams, M. B.(1995). Using interpretation to manage nature-based tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 4(2): 81-94.
Paradise, T.R.(1995). Sandstone weathering thresholds in Petra, Jordan. Physical Geography, 16: 205 – 222.
Paradise, T.R.(2000). Sandstone architectural deterioration in Petra, Jordan. Proceedings UNESCO Congress on Stone Deterioration and Conservation, Venice, Italy, June 17th.
Paradise, T.R.(2002). Sandstone weathering and aspect in Petra, Jordan. Z. Geomorphology, 46: 1 –17.
Pentecost, A.(1991). The Weathering rates of some sandstone cliffs, CENTRAL ENGLAND. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 16: 83–91
Petuskey, W. T., Richardson, D. A., & Dolske, D. A.(1995). Aspects of the deterioration of sandstone masonry in Anasazi dwelling ruins at Mesa Verde National Park, Colorado, USA. The Science of the Total Environment, 167: 145-159.
Phillips, J.D.(2001). Inherited versus acquired complexity in east Texas weathering profiles. Geomorphology, 40: 1 – 14.
Pope, G. A., Meierding, T. C., & Paradise, T. R.(2002). Geomorphology’s role in the study of weathering of cultural stone. Geomorphology, 47: 211-225.
Prescott-Allen, R.(1997). Barometer of sustainability: Measuring and communicating wellbeing and sustainable development. In IUCN, An approach to assessing progress toward sustainability: Tools and training series for institutions, field teams and collaborating agencies. Gland: IUCN.
Richey, J. S., Mar, B. W., & Horner, R. R.(1985). The Delphi technique in environmental assessment: Implementation and effectiveness. Journal of Environmental Management, 21(2): 135-146.
Robinson, D.A., & Williams, R.B.G.(1989). Polygonal cracking of sandstone at Fontainebleau, France. Geomorphology, 33(1): 59– 72.
Robinson, D.A., & Williams, R.B.G.(1999). The weathering of Hastings Beds sandstone gravestones in South East England. In: Jones, M.S., Wakefield, R.D.(Eds.), Aspects of Stone Weathering, Decay, and Conservation. Proceedings of the 1997 Stone Weathering and Atmospheric Pollution Network Conference(SWAPNet ’97). London: Imperial College.
Rodriguez-Navarro, C. & Doehne, E.(1998). Salt weathering: Influence of evaporation rate, supersaturation and crystallization pattern. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. 24(3): 191–209.
Ross, S., & Wall, G.(1999a). Ecotourism: Towards congruence between theory and practice. Tourism Management, 20(1): 123-132.
Ross, S., & Wall, G.(1999b). Evaluating ecotourism: The case of North Sulawasi, Indonesia. Tourism Management, 20(6): 673-682.
Rögner, K.(1988). Measurements of cavernous weathering at Machtesh Hagadol(Negev, Israel)a semiquantitative study. Catena Supplement, 12: 67– 76.
Saaty, T.L.(1980). The Analytic Hierarchy Process. McGraw-Hill, New York.
Sancho, C., & Benito, G.(1990). Factors controlling tafoni weathering in the Ebro Basin(NE Spain). Geomorphology, 34(2): 165– 177.
Schmidt, K.H.(1989). The significance of scarp retreat for Cenozoic landform evolution on the Colorado Plateau, USA. Earth Surface Processes and Landform, 14: 93– 104.
Takahashi, K., Suzuki, T. & Matsukura, Y.(1994). Erosion rates of a sandstone used for a masonry bridge pier in the coastal spray zone. In: Robinson, D.A., Williams, R.B.G.(Eds.), Rock Weathering and Landform Evolution. New York: Wiley and Sons, 175-192.
Taylor, R. E., & Judd, L. L.(1989). Delphi method applied to tour- ism. In S. Witt, & L. Moutinho(Eds.), Tourism marketing and management handbook(pp. 95-99). New York: Prentice Hall.
Turkingtona, A. V. & Paradise, T. R.(2005). Sandstone weathering: a century of research and innovation, Geomorphology, 67: 229–253
Tsaur, S. H., Lin, Y. C., & Lin, J. H.(2006). Evaluating ecotourism sustainability from the integrated perspective of resource, community and tourism. Tourism Management, 27: 640-653.
Twining-Ward, L. & Butler, R.(2002). Implementing STD on Small Island: Development and use of sustainable tourism development indicators in Samon. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 10(5), 363–387.
United Nations Educaitonal, Scientific and Cultural Organization(1999). Operational Guidelines for UNESCO Geoparks. United Nations Educaitonal, Scientific and Cultural Organization.
Wallace, G. N., & Pierce, S. M.(1996). An evaluation of ecotourism in Amazonas, Brazil. Annals of Tourism Research, 23(4): 843-873.
Warke, P.A., Smith, B.J.,& Magee, R.W.(1996). Thermal response characteristics of stone: implications for weathering of soiled surfaces in urban environments. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 21: 295 – 306.
Warscheid, T. & Braams, J.(2000)Biodeterioration of stone: a review. Internationl. Biodeterior Biodegrad, 46: 343– 368.
World Commission of Environment and Development(1987). Our common future. New York: Oxford University.
Wheeller, B., Hart, T., & Whysall, P.(1990). Application of the Delphi technique: A reply to Green, Hunter and Moore. Tourism Management ,11(2): 121-122.
Williams, R.B.G., & Robinson, D.A.(2000). Effects of aspect on weathering: anomalous behaviour of sandstone gravestones in southeast England. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 25: 135–144.
World Tourism Organisation(1993). Indicators for the sustainable management of tourism. Winnipeg: WTO.
World Tourism Organization(1996). What tourism managers need to know: A practical guide to the development and use of indicators of sustainable tourism, Madrid, Spain: The World Tourism Organization.
World Tourism Organization(1998). Guide for local authorities on development sustainable tourism. Madrid, Spain: The World Tourism Organization.
Young, R.W.(1988). Quartz etching and sandstone karst: examples from the East Kimberleys, Northwestern Australia. Geomorphology, 32(4): 409 – 423.
Yatsu, E.(1988). The Nature of Weathering(p.622). Tokyo: Sozosha.

《網路資料》
呂國寶(2005年9月9日)，颱風+地震_野柳駱駝峰部分坍塌_女王頭面臨斷頭，東森新聞，線上資料：[http://www.ettoday.com/2005/09/09 /329-1842255.htm]，2005/9/20瀏覽，。
交通部觀光局(2007)，1986~2006年台閩地區主要觀光遊憩區遊客人數月別統計，交通部觀光局行政資訊系統，線上資料：[http:// 202.39.225.136] ，2007/11/16瀏覽。
李光中(2006)，社區參與地景保育之研究-以台東利吉惡地為例，行政院國家科學委員會補助專題研究計畫成果報告。線上資料：[https://nscnt12.nsc.gov.tw /prquery/WPR21010.asp?KIND=1&Query_Type=OLD]，2008/5/29瀏覽。
萬里鄉戶政事務所(2008)，96年12月人口統計，台北縣萬里鄉戶政事務所歷年人口統計，取自：[http://www.wanli.ris.tpc.gov.tw]，2008/5/29瀏覽。
國科會(1999)，永續台灣評量系統，永續發展願景與策略。線上資料[http://www.law.ntu.edu.tw/sustain]，2001/11/20瀏覽。
陳文山(2005)野柳岬形成史，阿山的地科研究室，線上資料[http://ashan. gl.ntu.edu.tw/ ndex.htm]， 2008/5/29瀏覽。
Ablovatski, A.(2004). Multicriteria Decision Aid. Online: [http://mcda. dynalias. Org]. 2008/5/29.
Global Geopark Network(2008). Visit geoparks. UNESCO Global Geopark Network. Online：[http://www.globalgeopark.org/publish/portal1/tab133/], 2008/7/3.
International Union of Geological Science(2005). Annual Report of the International Union of Geological Sciences for 2005. Online: [http://www.iugs.org /PDF/IUGS 2005 Annual Report.pdf], 2008/5/20.
United Nations Educaitonal, Scientific and Cultural Organization(2007). Guidelines and Criteria for National Geoparks seeking UNESCO’s assistance to join the Global Geoparks Network. Online: [http://www. globalgeopark.org/Portal1 /InfoModule_878/617.htm]. 2007/11/20.