研究生: |
賈紅鶯 |
---|---|
論文名稱: |
以結構─策略學派的觀點建構一個家族治療的改變歷程 |
指導教授: | 陳秉華 |
學位類別: |
博士 Doctor |
系所名稱: |
教育心理與輔導學系 Department of Educational Psychology and Counseling |
論文出版年: | 2000 |
畢業學年度: | 88 |
語文別: | 中文 |
論文頁數: | 395 |
中文關鍵詞: | 結構─策略家族治療 、詮釋性研究的微觀分析 、家庭互動結構 、治療介入 |
論文種類: | 學術論文 |
相關次數: | 點閱:393 下載:42 |
分享至: |
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
本研究係以結構─策略家族治療的觀點,對某市立醫院家族治療門診中一個睡眠障礙、酗酒大學生家庭的家族治療歷程進行觀察及詮釋。研究者以詮釋性研究的微觀分析法對二十次的治療過程錄影帶與治療者、評判員共同進行分析,得到以下幾方面的重要發現。
一、 結構─策略家庭治療者對〝問題〞的建構:
家庭對問題的看法是找出〝病因〞的「癥狀」架構,治療者則是提出互動、多元因果的「系統」架構。
二、 治療者的介入
包含「順應家庭結構」、「挑戰家庭結構」、「挑戰家庭的問題架構」、「治療關
係的介入」、「策略性的介入」、「挑戰個人內在」、「其他」等七大部分的介入。治療者最經常出現的為「挑戰家庭結構」,另一面又同時在「順應家庭結構」的治療介入。
三 、家庭互動結構的發展歷程
家庭的互動結構隨著IP癥狀的變化,歷經以下六個階段的轉變歷程:(A)家庭為IP癥狀求助(B)IP癥狀改善而家庭關係的衝突浮現(A’)IP癥狀發作與家庭結構被挑戰(B’)IP癥狀改善與家庭結構回穩的抗衡 (A”)IP癥狀再復發與家庭結構改變(B”)癥狀消失與家庭結構的改變。家庭的互動結構隨著癥狀的「復發─改善」的螺旋曲線而循環進展。
四、 治療介入發展階段的歷程
伴隨家庭結構的改變歷程,治療介入也形成六個階段的發展歷程如下:(A)使家庭參與治療 (B)建立信任與合作的關係(A’)順應癥狀發作對家庭結構挑戰(B’)治療第二階段的系統架構(A”)對夫妻結構的挑戰(B”)改變與結束。本研究發現癥狀除了對家庭系統有癥狀功能之外,對治療介入的發展也同樣具有正面功能。
五、治療者介入遇見的阻抗
治療者在進行家族治療介入時會遇到的阻抗包括:(一)治療過程出現的阻抗(二)治療技術介入的阻抗(三)治療者的系統架構面對家庭癥狀架構的阻抗(四)來自家庭內部的權力衝突的阻抗。治療者對阻抗的轉化的介入包括:重新框架家庭的問題觀; 尊重父親的癥狀架構;刻意忽略或淡化家庭出現的阻抗的訊息;順應家庭的權力與階層來進行挑戰。
研究者進一步就這個家族治療過程所反應的社會意義,包括:(一)家庭對問題「病」的建構所反應的社會意義(二)家庭結構反應的社會文化(三)治療介入反應的社會文化進行討論,進而對進行一個詮釋性研究的歷程提出結論與建議,作為未來家庭治療理論、實務及研究的參考。
中文部分
吳就君(民75)家族治療-理論與實務。台北,大洋出版社。
李維榕(民89) 誰人可以賦權始能?應用心理研究,第六期,出版中。
楊連謙、董秀珠(民86) 結構-策略取向家族治療。台北,心理出版社。
楊連謙、董秀珠(民88) 週三家族治療門診之三年回顧。台北市立療養院民國八十七年年報暨三十週年特刊。台北市立療養院編印,128-135。
楊連謙(民88) 以整體觀點來建構的精神科復健病房。台北市立療養院民國八十七年年報暨三十週年特刊。台北市立療養院編印,136-144。
楊連謙(民89) 婚姻治療中賦權始能的歷程-病態嫉妒個案的經驗。應用心理研究,第三期,第五期,213-250。
葉光輝、孫世維、利翠珊、趙淑珠(民86)家庭心理學的開展與研究特點。中華心理衛生學刊,10(2),19-43。
鄭玉英、王行編譯(民78)家庭重塑-探尋根源之旅。台北,心理出版社。
賈紅鶯(民80)父母自我分化、子女自我分化與子女適應水準關係之研究-Bowen
家庭系統理論之驗證。國立台灣師範大學教育心理與輔導研究所碩士論文。
賈紅鶯(民87) 由家庭系統看家庭關係,諮商與輔導,148,6-10。
賈紅鶯(民88)家族治療理論的建構與解構─我對家族治療的一些省思,輔導季刊,9-14 。
英文部分
Anderson , H . & Goolishian , H . A .(1988) . Human systems as linguistic systems : Preliminary and evolving ideas about the implications for clinical theory . Family Process , 27 , 371-394 .
Anderson , H. & Ggoolishian , H . A . (1990) . Beyond cybernetics : Comments on Atkinson & Heath’s Further thoughts on second-order family therapy. Family Process , 29 , 157-163 .
Atkinson , B . J . & Heath , A . W . (1990) . Further thoughts on second-order
family therapy- This time it’s personal . Family Process , 29 , 145-155.
Bateson , G . , Jackson , D . D . , Haley , J . , & Weakland , J . (1956) . Toward a theory of schizophrenia . Behavioral Science , 1 , 251-264.
Bateson , G . (1972) . Steps to an ecology of mind . New York : Ballantine.
Bateson , G . (1978) . Theory versus empiricism . In Milton M. Berger(Eds.) , Beyond the double bind . New York : Brunner/Mazel.
Bateson , G . & Bateson , C . (1987) . Angels fear. New York : Macmillan.
Becvar , D , S. & Becvar , R . J . (1999). Systems theory and family Therapy . University Press of America , Inc .
Benjamin , L . , Foster , S . , Roberto , L . & Estroff , S . (1986) . Breaking the family code : Analysis of videotapes of family interactions by structural analysis of social behavior ( SASB) . In L . Greenberg & W . Pinsof (Eds.), The Pychotherapeutic process : A research handbook (pp.391-349) . New York : Guilford Press.
Benjamin , O . & Sullivan , O . (1996) . The importance of difference :
conceptualising increased flexibility in gender relations at home . The Editorial Board of The Sociological Review1996 . Cambridge : Blackwell Publishers .
Bertalanffy , L .Von (1968) . General system theory . New York : George Braziller .
Bochner , Arther , P . (1975) . Family communucation research : A critical review of
approaches,methodologies and subtantive findings.Paper presented at the 1975
Prudue post Doctoral Honors Seminar.
Boscolo , L . Cecchin , G . , Hoffman , L . & Penn , P . (1987) . Milan system family therapy : Conversations in theory and Practice . New York : Basic Books.
Cecchin , G . (1987) . Hypothesizing , circularity , and neutrality revisited : An invitation to curiosity . Family Process , 26 , 405-413 .
Chubb , H . (1990) . Looking system as process . Family Process , 29 , 169-175.
Colapinto , J . (1991) . Structural family therapy. In A. S. Gurman & D. P. Kniskern (Eds.) , Handbook of family therapy . New York : Brunner/Mazel.
Combrinck-Graham , L . (1985) . A developmental model for family systems . Family Process , 24(2) , 1-8.
Constantine(1986) . Couple and individual therapy scales . Journal and Marital Therapy . 12 , 137-151 .
Dell , P . F . (1982) . Beyond homeostasis : Toward a concept of coherence . Family Process , 24 , 139-150 .
Elliott , R . (1984) . A discovery-oriented approach to significant change events in
Psychotherapy interpersonal process recall and comprehensive process analysis
. In L . N. Rice & L . S . Greenberg (Eds.) , Patterns of change : Intensive analysis of psychotherapy process (pp.249-286) . New York : Guilford.
Erickson , F . & Shultz , J . (1982) . The counselor as gatekeeper : Social interaction in interviews. New York : Academic Press.
Erickson , F . & Mohatt , G . (1982) . Cutural organization of participation structures in two classrooms of Indian students . In George Spindler (Ed . ) , Doing the ethnography of Schooling : Educational anthropology in action . CBS College Publishing .
Erickson , F . (1975) . Gatekeeping and the melting pot : Interaction in counseling encounters.Harvard Educational Review , 45(1) , 44-70 .
Erickson , F . (1982) . The analysis of audiovisual records as a primary data source . In A. Grimshaw (Ed . ) , Sound-image records in social interaction research . Special Issue of the Journal of Sociological Methods and Research , 11(2) , 213- 232 .
Erickson , F . (1986) . Qualitative methods in research on Handbook of Research on Teaching . New York : Ameraican Educational Research Association MacMillan Publishing company .
Erickson , F . (1992) . Ethnographic Microanalysis of inteeeeraction . In M. D. LeComple, W. L. Millroy. & Pressle, J. (Eds.) ,The Haandbook of qualitative research in education . Academic Press , Inc .
Friedlander , M . L . & Wildman , J . (1991) . Interpersonal control in structural and Milan Systemic family therapy . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy . 17(4) , 395- 408 .
Gale , J . E. (1989) . Pursuing a therapeutic agenda:conversation analysis of a marital therapy session . A Dissertation in home economics , Texas Tech University.
George , S . & Barbara . P . (1986) . Family therapy in the school setting : A case study . Journal of Counseling and Development . December , 65 , 200- 203.
Gergen , K . (1985) . The social constructionist in modern psychology.American Psychologist , 40 , 266-275 .
Gergen , K . (1991) . The saturated self . New York : Basic books.
Goldenberg , I . & Goldbeerg , H . (1995) . Family therapy-an overview. Brooks/Cole . A division of international Thomson Publishing Inc.
Goolishian , H . & Anderson , H . (1992) . Strategy and intervention versus nonintervention : a Matter of theory?Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. 18(1) , 5-15.
Greenberg , L . S. & Pinsof , W. M. (1986a). Process research:current trends and future perspectives. In Greenberg & Pinsof (Eds.) , The Psychotherapy Process : A research handbook . New York : Guilford.
Greenberg , L . S . & Pinsof , W . M . (Eds.) (1986b).The psychotherapeutic process:
A research hand book.New York : Guilford Press .
Greenberg , G . S . (1977). The family interactive perspective : A study and eximination of the work of Don D. Jackson. Family Process, 16, 385-412.
Gumperz , J . J . (1982) . Discourse strategies. England : Cambridge University Press.
Gurman , A . S. , Kniskern , D . P . & Pinsof , W . M . (1986) .Research on the process and outcome of marital and family therapy . In S . L . Garfield & A . E . Bergin (Eds.) Handbook of psychotherapy and bahavior change. New York:John Wiley & Sons.
Haley , J . (1963). Strategies of psychotherapy. New York : Grune & Stratton.
Haley , J . (1976) . Problem-Solving Therapy : New strategies for family therapy . CA: Jossey-Bass , Inc.
Hamersley , M . (1992) . What’s wrong with ethnography . New York : Routledge.
Hazelrigg , M . D . , Cooper . H . M . & Borduin , C . M . (1987) . Evaluation the
effectiveness of family therapies : An integrative review and analysis .
Psychological Bulletin , 101 , 329-442.
Held , B . S . (1992) . The problem of strategy within the systemic therapies.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy , 18 , 25-34 .
Hoffman , L . (1988) . Reply to Stuart Golann . Family Process , 27 , 65-68.
Hoffman , L. (1992). A reflexive stance for family therapy. In McNamee,S. & Gergen . K . J . (Eds .) , Therapy as construction. California : SAGE Publications Inc.
Hoshmand, L . S . T. (1989). Alternative research paradigms : A review and teaching proposal . The Counnseling Psychologist . 17 , 1-80 .
Jackson, D . D . (1965) . The study of the family . Family Process , 4(1) , 11-20.
Josephfrey , III. (1984) . A family/systems approach to illness-maintaining befaviors
In chronically III adolescents . 23 , 251-260 .
Keeney & Sprenkle (1982) . Ecosystemic Epistemology:Critical Implications for the Aeathetics and Pragmatics of Family Therapy . Family Process , 21 , 1-19.
Keeney , B . P . (1983) . Aesthetics of change . New York : Guilford Press.
Kuehl , B . P. , Newfield , N . A . & Joanning , H . (1990) . A client-based description of family therapy . Journal of Family Psychology ,3(3) , 310-321.
Leininger , M . M . (1985) . Qualitative research methods in nursing . New York : Grune & Stratton.
Liddle , H . A .(1991) . Empirical values and the culture of family therapy.Journal of
Marital and Family Therapy , 17(4) , 327-348.
Madanes , C . (1981) . Strategic family therapy . San Francisco : Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Marcus G., & Fisher, M . (1986) . Antropology as cultural critique : An experimental moment in the human sciences . Chicago : Universityof Chicago Press .
Mazza , J . (1984) . Symptom utilization in strategic therapy . Family Process ,
23 , 487- 500.
Maturana , H . R . & Vearela , F . J . (1992) . The tree of knowledge . Boston , MA :
Shambhala .
McNamee , S . & Gergen , K . (1992) . Therapy as social construction . Newbury Park , CA : Sage.
Michael White (1979) . Structural and strategic approaches to psychosomatic families. Family Process, 8(3) , 1-8.
Minuchin (1974) Families and Family Therapy.President and Fellow of Harvard College.
Minuchin , S . & Fishman , H . C . (1981) . Family therapy techniques . Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
Minuchin , S . (1984) . Family Kaleidoscope . Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
Minuchin , S . (1989). My voices:an historical perspective.Journal of Family Therapy , 2, 69-80.
Minuchin , S . & Nichols , M . P . (1993) . Family healing- strategies for hope and understanding . New York : Simon & Schuster.
Minuchin , S . , Wai-Yung Lee , & Simon , G . M . (1996) . Mastering family therapy . New York : John Wiley & Sons ,Inc .
Moon , S . M . , Dillon , D . R. & Sprenkle , D . H . (1990) . Family therapy and qualitatative research . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy , 16 , 357-374.
Newfield , N . , Seels , S . P . , Smith , T . E . ,Newfield , S . & Newfield (1996) . Ethnographic research methods : creating a clinical science of the humanities. In D. H . Sprenkle & S . M . Moon (Eds.) , Research methods in family therapy. New York : The Guilford Press.
Nichols , M . P . (1997) . The art of the enactment : How to get real conversation going in the consulting room. Netwworker, November/December.
Pearson(1974) . Prisons of love : the reification of the family in family therapy. In N . Armistead (Ed.) , Reconstructing Social Psychology , Baltimore , Penguin.
Pinsof , W . M . (1981). Family therapy process research. In A . S . Gurman & D . P . Kniskern (Eds. ) , Handbook of family therapy . New York:Brunner/Mazel.
Pinsof , W . M . (1986). The process of family therapy : The development of the family therapist coding system. In L . S. Greenberg & W.M. Pinsof (Eds.) , The Psychotherapeutic process : A research handbook.New York : The Guilford Press.
Pinsof , W . M . & Catherall , D . R . (1986). The intergrative psychotherapy alliance : Family , Couple and individual therapy scales . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy . 12 , 137-151.
Pinsof , W . M . (1989) . A conceptual framework and Methodological criteria for family therapy process research.Journal of Consuting and Clinical Psychology . 57 (1) , 53-59.
Rice , L . M . & Greenberg , L . S . (1984) . The research paradigm . In L . N . Rice & L . S . Greenberg (Eds.) , Patterns of change : Intensive analysis of psychotherapy Process , New York : Guilford.
Scheflen , A. E. (1973). Communicational structure : Analysis of a psychotherapy transaction . Bloomington : Indiana University Press.
Selles , S . P . , Smith , T . E . , Coe , M . J . ,Yoshioka , M . & Robbins , J . (1994) . An ethnography of couple and therapist experiences in reflecting team practice . Journal of Marital and Family therapy . 20(3) , 247-266.
Sells , S . P. , Smith , T . E . & Moon , S . (1996) . An ethnographic study of client
and therapist Perceptions of therapy sffectiveness in a university-based training clinic . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy . 22(3) , 321-342 .
Selvini Palazzoli , M . Boscolo , L . , Cecchin , G . , & Prata , G . (1978) .
Paradox and counterparadox : A new model in the therapy of the family in schizophrenic transaction . New York : Aronson .
Selvini-Palazzoli , M . (1986) . Toward a general model of psychotic family games . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy , 12 (4) , 339-349.
Simon , G . M . (1992) . Having a second-order mind while doing first-order therapy . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy . 18 , 377-387.
Simon , G . M . (1995) . A revisionist rendering of structural family therapy.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy . 21(1) , 17-26.
Smith , T . E . , Winton , M . , & Yoshioka , M . (1992) . A qualitative understanding of reflective-teams II:Therapist’ perspective Contemporary Family Therapy . 14 , 419-432.
Smith , T . E . , Sells , S . P . & Clevenger , T . (1994) . Ethnographic content analysis of couple and therapist perceptions in a reflecting team setting . Journal of Marital and Family therapy . 20(3) , 267-286.
Sprandly , J . (1980). Participant observation . New York : Holt , Rinehart & Winston.
Tomm , K . & Wright , L . (1979) . Training in family therapy : perceptual , conceptual and executive skills . Family Process , 18(2) , 227-250.
Wai-Yung Lee & Raymond Chan (1992) . Structural family therapy for a Chinese Family-Children of sleeping beauty & superman . paper presented at the Psychotherapy for the Chinese-an international conference , November , 9-10 , Hong Kong.
Watzlawick , P . , Beavin , J . , & Jackson , D . (1967) . Pragmatics of
human communication . New York : W . W . Norton.
Watzlawick , P . , Weakland , J . & Fisch , R .(1974) . Change : Principles of problem formation and problem resolution . New York : W . W . Norton.
West , C . & Zimmerman , D . H .(1987) .Doing Gender , Gender and society , 1 , 125-151.
Wetchler , J . L . (1995) . A conservative response to Simon’s revision of structural family Therapy . Journal of Marital and Family Therapy , 21(1) , 27-31.