簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 黃耀儀
Huang, Yao-Yi
論文名稱: Building National Taiwan Museum (1915)- Perspectives on the West in Taiwan under Japanese Rule
Building National Taiwan Museum (1915)- Perspectives on the West in Taiwan under Japanese Rule
指導教授: 辛蒂庫絲
Candida Syndikus
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 藝術史研究所
Graduate Institute of Art History
論文出版年: 2020
畢業學年度: 108
語文別: 英文
論文頁數: 151
中文關鍵詞: 臺灣總督府博物館臺灣博物館野村一郎(1868-1942)博物館建築歷史主義英雄崇拜日治時期臺北都市計畫
英文關鍵詞: Taiwan Viceroy's Museum, National Taiwan Museum, Architect Ichiro Nomura (1868-1942), Museum Architecture, Historicism, Hero Cult, Taipei City Plan during the Japanese Era
DOI URL: http://doi.org/10.6345/NTNU202001617
論文種類: 學術論文
相關次數: 點閱:339下載:129
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報

國立臺灣博物館是臺灣唯一不僅保留了其原本歷史主義形式的建物,而且繼續履行其最初展覽館功能的日治時期官方建築。為了紀念日本第四任總督兒玉源太郎(Gentarō Kodama,1852–1906年)和民政長官後藤新平(Shinpei Gotō,1857–1929年)任內對臺灣的貢獻,日本殖民政府在臺北於1915年建造了這座當時名為臺灣總督府博物館的建築。開館時其功能為一自然史博物館,收藏並展示臺灣的自然歷史文物。而博物館所在地點,通過直視軸(今館前路)與當時的臺北火車站相連,兩者都是20世紀初台北市區結構中令人印象深刻的地標。這座對稱的博物館建築展現了歷史主義風格的融合,中央由一個方形空間和圓頂組成,連接的兩個側翼,底端各有一個方形的樓閣,顯然受到了西方建築模型的影響。博物館的代表性地點及其新古典主義的外觀表明了日本殖民政府試圖通過建造這樣的建築物,向世界展示進步文明的形象,而使其在臺灣的殖民政權合法化。
然而,儘管具有如此的歷史價值,在文獻上對臺博館建築物的形式和結構仍未進行實質性的分析;也缺乏其源自西方建築具體來源的深入研究。為了能更好地理解建築物的結構並尋查可能影響其最終形式的來源,本論文將首先闡明臺博館的歷史背景,而這意味著要對當時的歷史文獻進行分析。在此一過程中,尤其將特別注意博物館建築設計師野村一郎(Ichirō Nomura,1868–1942)在1910年前往歐美,尤其是倫敦和紐約,的旅程中,可能看到過哪些建築物而成為影響臺博館建築設計的參考原型。最後,對於日本殖民政府在博物館內紀念兩位高官和其背後所隱含的英雄崇拜之面向也將納入討論;而博物館作為紀念館的起源將受到詳細的檢視。

The National Taiwan Museum is the only exhibition venue in the country that not only has widely preserved its original historicist form, but continues to fulfill its initial function as an exhibition venue. The Japanese colonial government in Taiwan constructed this building in 1915 to commemorate Japan’s fourth Viceroy, Gentarō Kodama (1852–1906), and to honor the Chief Civil Administrator, Shinpei Gotō (1857–1929). The Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum (臺灣總督府博物館), as it was then called, was founded by the Japanese government as a museum of natural history. The site chosen was linked by a straight visual axis with the Taipei Railway Station, both serving as impressive landmarks within the urban fabric of early-20th-century Taipei. Displaying a historicist mixture of styles, the symmetrical building, which is composed of one central block with a dome on top and two connecting wings with a square pavilion at each end, was obviously influenced by models of Western architecture. The museum’s representative location and its neo-classical façade show that by creating such a building, the Japanese colonial government tried to legitimize its regime in Taiwan by presenting a progressive and civilized image toward the world.
Albeit its historical value, substantial analysis of the building’s form and structure has not yet been undertaken. In-depth research into concrete sources stemming from Western architecture is also lacking. In order to better understand the building’s structure and to find the sources, which might have influenced its final form, the present thesis will, initially, clarify the historical background of the project, which implies an analysis of written sources from the time. Special attention will be paid to the question, which museum buildings architect Ichirō Nomura (1868–1942) had possibly seen during a journey undertaken to the West, and to London and New York, in particular, and which of these could have been models for the Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum. Finally, the aspect of commemorating two highly decorated dignitaries of the Japanese colonial government in the museum and the respective hero cult will be taken into account. The origins of a museum as memorial will be under close scrutiny.

Table of Contents English Abstract i Chinese Abstract ii 1. Introduction 1 2. State of Research 3 3. Historical Background 12 3.1 Collections in Taiwan before 1908 12 3.2 The Museum of the Production Bureau in 1908 13 3.3 Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum in 1915 15 3.4 National Taiwan Museum after 1945 17 4. The Designer of the Museum 18 4.1 The Architect Ichirō Nomura 18 4.2 Architect Nomura’s Journey to the West in 1910 19 5. The Western Style Museum Building 24 5.1 Japanese Architecture in Colonial Taiwan 24 5.2 General Description and Formal Analysis 25 6. Western Features of the Museum Architecture 31 6.1 The Greek-Doric Order 31 6.2 The Entrance Hall and its Beaux-Arts Style 36 6.3 The Pavilions and their Modernist Features 41 6.4 The Ornaments and Stylistic Variations 46 7. The Memorial Function of the National Taiwan Museum 51 7.1 The Entrance Hall as a Place for Commemoration 51 7.2 Honorary Halls in Western Tradition 53 7.3 The Statues of Gentarō Kodama and Shinpei Gotō 54 8. Conclusion 58 9. Bibliography 61 Appendix I: Translated Sources 69 Appendix II: Illustrations 77 Photo Credits 145

1. Literature in English
Abt, Jeffrey, Katherine Stadtmiller and Helen Searing, “Museum,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://0-www.oxfordartonline.com.opac.lib.ntnu.edu.tw/, accessed on June 17, 2017
Barringer, Tim and Tom Flynn, Colonialism and the Object: Empire, Material Culture and the Museum, London: Routledge, 1998
Baum, Robert and Jan Letzel, in: Japan Architect, a web database at https://japan-architect.jimdo.com/foreign-architects-in-japan/jan-letzel/, accessed on June 23, 2017
Bennett, Tony, The Birth of the Museum: History, Theory, Politics, London: Routledge, 1995
Bergdoll, Barry, European Architecture 1750-1890, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000
Bouvet, Vincent, “Deglane, Henri-Adolphe-Auguste,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://doi.org/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T021825, accessed on July 19, 2020
Bouwers, Eveline G., Public Pantheons in Revolutionary Europe: Comparing Cultures of Remembrance, c. 1790–1840, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012
Bressani, Martin, “The Spectacle of the City of Paris from 25bis rue Franklin,” in: Assemblage 12, 1990, pp. 84–107
Camp II, John McK., The Athenian Agora: A Short Guide to Excavations, Athens: American School of Classical Studies at Athens, 2003
Chang, Han-Yu and Ramon H. Myers, “Japanese Colonial Development Policy in Taiwan, 1895–1906: A Case of Bureaucratic Entrepreneurship,” in: The Journal of Asian Studies 22, no. 4, 1963, pp. 433–449
Codell, Julie F. (ed.), The Political Economy of Art: Making the Nation of Culture, Madison: Fairliegh Dickinson University Press, 2008
Connor, T. P.“Pattern Book,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://0-doi.org.opac.lib.ntnu.edu.tw/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T065801, accessed on July 20, 2020
Cooper, Carol, A study of architecture for art, design and visual media in the West Midlands from the 20th century onwards based on the perceptions of individuals, PhD thesis, University of Wolverhampton (United Kingdom), Wolverhampton 2017
Crook, Joseph Mordaunt, The Greek Revival: Neo-Classical Attitudes in British Architecture 1760-1870, London: John Murray, 1972
Davis, Paul and David Hemsoll, “Renaissance Balusters and the Antique,” in: Architectural History 26, 1983, pp. 1–23, 117–122
Dillon, Sheila and Elizabeth Palmer Baltes, “Honorific Practices and the Politics of Space on Hellenistic Delos: Portrait Statue Monuments Along the Dromos,” in: American Journal of Archaeology 117, no. 2, April 2013, pp. 207–246
Dinsmoor, William Bell, “The Athenian Treasury as Dated by Its Ornament,” in: American Journal of Archaeology 50, no. 1, 1946, pp. 86–121
Finn, Dallas, Meiji Revisited: the Sites of Victorian Japan, New York: Waetherhill, 1995
Fu, Chao-Ching, “Beaux-Arts Practice and Education by Chinese Architects in Taiwan,” in: Jeffrey W. Cody, Nancy S. Steinhardt and Tony Atkin (eds.), Chinese Architecture and the Beaux-Arts, Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 2011, pp. 127–143
Gerson, Martha Blythe Gerson, “A Glossary of Robert Adam’s Neo-Classical Ornament” in: Architectural History 24, 1981, pp. 59–82
Glaeser, Ludwig, Architecture of Museums, New York: Museum of Modern Art, 1968
Greenough, Sarah, Alfred Stieglitz: The Key Set, vol. 2, Washington, D.C.: National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C., 2002
Guth, Christine, “Japanese 1868–1945: Art, Architecture, and National Identity” in: Art Journal 55, no. 3, 1996, pp. 16–20
Horster, Marita, “Castagnos Florentiner Fresken 1450–1457, Part II” in: Wallraf-Richartz-Jahrbuch 17, 1955, pp. 79–131
Isozaki, Arata, Japan-ness in Architecture, Cambridge: MIT Press, 2011
Jones, J., “Museum and Art Gallery Buildings in England, 1845–1914” in: Museum Journal 65, 1965, pp. 230–38; 1966, pp. 271–80
Langley, Samuel Pierpont, Memoir of George Brown Goode, 1851–1896, Washington, D. C.: Judd and Detweiler, 1897
Lehman, Geoff and Michael Weinman, The Parthenon and Liberal Education, New York: State University of New York Press, 2018
Lepik, Andres, Skyscrapers, Munich [et al.]: Prestel, 2008 (orig. edition, Munich [et al.]: Prestel, 2004)
Long, Christopher, “The Viennese Secessionsstil and Modern American Design,” in: Studies in the Decorative Arts 14, no. 2, 2007, pp. 6–44
Lorenz, Werner and Annegret Rohde, “Building with Iron in Nineteenth Century Bavaria – The Valhalla Roof Truss and its Architect, Leo von Klenze,” in: Construction History 17, 2001, pp. 55–74
Mackay, George Leslie, From Far Formosa: the Island, its People and Missions, 4th ed., New York: Fleming H. Revell Company, 1895
Moyano, Steve, “Quality vs. History: Schinkel’s Altes Museum and Prussian Arts Policy,” in: The Art Bulletin 72, no. 4, 1990, pp. 585–608.
Murphy Kevin D., “Modernism and architecture,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://doi.org/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T2271597, accessed on July 23, 2020
Mutsu, Hirokichi, “The Japan-British Exhibition, 1910,” in: Journal of the Royal Society of Arts 58, no. 2983, January 21, 1910, pp. 232–243
Naredi-Rainer, Paul von, Museum Buildings: A Design Manual, Basel: Birkhäuser, 2004
Neer, Richard T., “Framing the Gift: The Politics of the Siphnian Treasury at Delphi,” in: Classical Antiquity 20, no. 2, 2001, pp. 273–344
Nègre, Valerie, L’ornement en série. Architecture, terre cuite et carton-pierre, Sprimont: Pierre Mardaga éditeur, 2006
Nute, Kevin, “Frank Lloyd Wright and Japanese Architecture: A Study in Inspiration,” in: Journal of Design History 7, no. 3, 1994, pp. 169–185
—, Frank Lloyd Wright and Japan: the role of traditional Japanese art and architecture in the work of Frank Lloyd Wright, London and New York: Routledge, 2000
Oshima, Ken Tadashi, International Architecture in Interwar Japan: Constructing Kokusai Kenchiku, Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2009
Pevsner, Nikolaus, A History of Building Types, London: Thames and Hudson, 1976, pp. 111–38
Plagemann, Volker, Das deutsche Kunstmuseum 1790-1870: Lage, Baukörper, Raumorganisation, Bildprogramm, Munich: Prestel, 1967
Saalman, Howard, “Filippo Brunelleschi: Capital Studies,” in: The Art Bulletin 40, no. 2, 1958, pp. 113–137
Sadler, Arthur Lindsay, Japanese Architecture: A Short History, Tokyo: Tuttle, 2009
Sawada, Mitziko,Tokyo Life, New York Dreams: Urban Japanese Visions of America, 1890-1924, Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996
Stewart, David B., The Making of a Modern Japanese Architecture. From the Founders to Shinohara and Isozaki, Tokyo and New York: Kodansha International, 2002 (1st edition Tokyo: Kodansha International, 1987)
Stuart, James and Nicholas Revett, Antiquities of Athens: Measured and Delineated by James Stuart, FRS and FSA, and Nicholas Revett, Painters and Architects vol. III, London: John Nichols, 1794
Suzuki, Hiroyuki, “Josiah Conder,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://doi.org/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T019008, accessed on April 8th, 2020
Suzuki, Hiroyuki, “Kingo Tatsuno,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://doi.org/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T083455, accessed on April 8th, 2020
Tseng, Alice Yu-Ting, Styling Japan: The Case of Josiah Conder and the Museum at Ueno, Tokyo, in: Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 63, no. 4, 2004, pp. 472–497
Tseng, Alice Yu-Ting, The Imperial Museums of Meiji Japan: Architecture and the Art of the Nation, Seattle and London: University of Washington Press, 2008
Tyack, Geoffrey, “Smirke,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press at https://0-www.oxfordartonline.com.opac.lib.ntnu.edu.tw/, accessed on June 23, 2017
Watanabe, Hiroshi, The Architecture of Tokyo, Stuttgart: Menges, 2001
Wezel, Elsa van, “Die Konzeptionen des Alten und Neuen Museums zu Berlin und das sich wandelndehistorische Bewusstsein,” in: Jahrbuch der Berliner Museen vol. 43, 2001, Beiheft, pp. 3–244
Wilton-Ely, John, “Neo-classicism,” in: Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press, at https://doi.org/10.1093/gao/9781884446054.article.T061658, accessed on April 8th, 2018
Wittkower, Rudolf, “Pseudo-Palladian Elements in English Neo-Classical Architecture” in: Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 6, 1943, pp. 154–164
Yerkes, Carolyn, “The Grand Escalier at the Château de Versailles: The Monumental Staircase and its Edges,” in: The Princeton University Library Chronicle 76, no. 1–2, 2015, pp. 51–83
Zhu, Jianfei, Architecture of Modern China: A Historical Critique, London: Routledge, 2009

2. Literature in Chinese
Chang, Sheng-Ching, Deshi dushi guihua jing riben zhimin zhengfu dui taibeicheng guanting jizhongqu zhi yingxiang [The German Influence on Japanese Colonial Government’s City Plan in Taipei] (德式都市規劃經日本殖民政府對台北城官廳集中區之影響), Taipei: Fu Jen Catholic University Press, 2008
Chen, Qi-Nan and Zun-Xian Wang, Xiaoshi de bowuguan jiyi: zaoqi Taiwan de bowuguan lishi [The missing museum stories: the birth of museum in Taiwan] (消失的博物館記憶:早期台灣的博物館歷史), Taipei, 2009.
Chen, Qi-Nan, Diguo de xiangxiang tai bo guan de dansheng yu ri zhi taiwan de zhimin yishi [Imagination of the Empire: the Birth of the National Taiwan Museum] (帝國的想像:臺博館的誕生與日治臺灣的殖民意識), in: Shìjì tái bó, jìndài táiwān [Natioanl Taiwan Museum: Its Past and Future] (世紀臺博,近代臺灣), Taipei, 2008
Guo, Zhao-Li, Menghuan bowu cheng: yige xiandai xing de xun meng jihua [A dream city of museums: an experiencing project for modernity] (夢幻博物城:一個現代性的尋夢計畫), exhibition catalog, Taipei: National Taiwan Museum, 2015
Huang, Jun-Ming, Zongdu fu wuyu- Taiwan zongdu fu ji guandi de gushi [The story of Taiwan governor general’s office and residence] (總督府物語:台灣總督府暨官邸的故事), Taipei: Sunflower Culture, 2004
Huang, Shih-Chuan, Jianzhu yu zhimindi jingying- yi taibei shi wei li [Architecture under the Colonization in Taipei] (建築與殖民地經營─以台北市為例), in: Taiwan Bowu [Taiwan Natural Science] (臺灣博物季刊) 114, Jun., 2012, pp. 4–17
Huang, Shih-Chuan, Jianzhu jishu guanliao yu zhimindi jingying 1895-1922 [Architectural Technocrats and Colonial Managements 1895-1922] (建築技術官僚與殖民地經營1895-1922), Taipei: Yuan-Liou Publishing Co.,Ltd., 2012
Kang, Hsiu-Lan, Lishi jianzhu kongjian de wenhua quanshi yu zaixian- yi guoli Taiwan bowuguan wei li [Space Culture Representation of the Historical Building on the National Taiwan Museum] (歷史建築空間的文化詮釋與再現-以國立臺灣博物館為例), Master thesis of Taipei National University of the Arts, 2011
Li, Chien-Lang, Ershi shiji Taiwan jianzhu [Taiwanese architecture in 20th century] (20世紀台灣建築), Taipei: Taiwan Interminds Publishing Inc., 2001
Li, Chien-Lang, Jiegou- Li Chienlang shouhui tai bo jianzhu [Deconstruction- architectural drawings of the National Taiwan Museum by Li, Chien-Lang] (解構:李乾朗手繪臺博建築), Taipei: National Taiwan Museum, 2015
Li, Tzu-Ning (ed.), Bainian wuyu: Taiwan bowuguan shiji diancang zhuanji [The story of collection in a century: National Taiwan Museum centennial edition] (百年物語:臺灣博物館世紀典藏專輯), exhibition catalog, Taipei: National Taiwan Museum, 2009
Lin, Tzung-Kuei, Chenye shi de yuanliu yu yingxiang- Taiwan jindai jianzhu zhong hongbai hengtiao daishi fengge de shijie puxi [Origins and impact of the “Tatsuno Style”- red and white decoration bond of contemporary Taiwanese architecture in world systems] (「辰野式」的源流與影響-台灣近代建築中紅白橫條帶飾風格的世界譜系), in: Jian Zhu Xue Bao [Journal of Architecture] (建築學報), September 2013, no. 85, pp. 57–75
Lin, Zhou-Min and Wen-Kang Luo, Guoli Taiwan Bowuguan Zhengti Kongjian Fazhan Guihua Ji Zhoubian Huangjing Jingguan Gaishan Xibu Sheji [The overall plan of space development and the proposal for improving the surrounding environment of National Taiwan Museum] (國立臺灣博物館整體空間發展規劃暨周邊環境景觀改善細部設計), Taipei, 2010
Qian, Xiao-Shan, Zhimindi bowuguan yu ta zhe yixiang de zaixian- san ge riben zhimindi bowuguan de fenxi bijiao [Colonial museums and representations of others] (殖民地博物館與「他者」意象的再現—三個日本殖民地博物館的分析比較), Master thesis of National Taiwan University, 2006
Tsai, Long-Bao, Ri zhi shiqi Taiwan zongdufu tumu ju ying shank e jianzhu rencai de laiyuan ji qi jianshu: yi weishi guoji wei li [Source and Accomplishments of Architectural Technicians during Japanese Colonial Era: Case Study of Otsuzi Kuniyosi] (日治時期臺灣總督府土木局營繕課建築人才的來源及其建樹:以尾辻國吉為例), in: Taiwan shi yenjiu [Taiwan History Research] (臺灣史研究) 22, Sep., 2005, no. 3, pp. 51–96
Lin, Yi-Hung, A Review on the Architectural History of the Main Building, National Taiwan Museum (1) (台博本館修建史之再檢視(一)), Self-Research Project of National Taiwan Museum, 17, December, 2019 https://mocfile.moc.gov.tw/files/201912/4cf48db0-cc74-40f6-b6ca-f14fe9bf7bc9.pdf

3. Literature in Japanese
Association of Taiwan Museum (ed.), Tainanshū-ritsu kyōiku hakubutsukan no enkaku [History of Tainan State Education Museum] in: Kagaku no Taiwan [Science Taiwan] (科學の臺灣) first issue, November, 1933
Association of Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum (ed.), Taiwan sotokufu hakubutsukan an’nai [Information about Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum] (臺灣總督府博物館案內), Taipei, 1937
Ebisawa, Monado, 1867 Nen uin kyutei myujiamu kensetsu sekkei kyogi ni miru myujiamu kenchiku-zo [The Image of the Museum Architecture in the Design Competition for the Building of the Wiener Hofmuseen in 1867] in: Nihon kenchi kugakkai keikaku-kei ronbun-shū [ Journal of Architecture and Planning by the Architectural Institute of Japan] 73, 2008, pp. 1371–1378
Fujimori, Terunobu and Tan Wan (ed.), A Comprehensive Study of East Asian Architecture and Urban Planning: 1840–1945, Tokyo, 1996
Horiguchi, Katsumi, Osakafu Tachi boeki-kan no hensen [Transition of Osaka Prefectural Commercial Exhibition Hall] in: Osaka a ka ibuzu [Official Bulletin of Osaka Prefectural Archives] 18, Mar., 1996, pp. 1–2
Ikegami, Shigeyasu, Kōbudaigakkō sōsetsu-ki no shozō kenchiku yōsho ni tsuite [Foreign Architetural Books Owned by Kobu-Dai-Gakko, Imperial College of Engineering, in Its Infancy] in: Nihon kenchi kugakkai keikaku-kei ronbun-shū [ Journal of Architecture and Planning by the Architectural Institute of Japan] 618, 2007, pp. 135–141
Yasuhiko Nishizawa: Higashi ajia no nihon jin kenchikka: Seiki matsu kara nitchu senso [Japanese Architects in East Asia: From the End of the Century to Second Sino-Japanese War] (東アジアの日本人建築家 世紀末から日中戦争), Tokyo: Kashiwashobo Publishing Co., Ltd., 2011
Nomura, Ichirō, About Taipei’s Urban Renewal, in: Kentiku Zassi [Journal of Architecture and Building Spaces] 378, 1918, pp. 29–32
Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum (ed.), Hakubutsukan an’nai [Information about Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum] (博物館案內), Taipei, 1934
Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum (ed.), Sotokufu hakubutsukan 30-Shūnen kinenronbunshū [Proceedings for the 30th Anniversary of Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum] (總督府博物館三十年記念論文集), Taipei, 1939
Taiwan Viceroy’s Office Museum (ed.), Taiwan hakubutsukan no tebiki [A Guide to the Taiwan Museum] (臺灣博物館の手引), Taipei, 1926
Takaishi Gumi (ed.), Kodama sōtoku Gotō minseichōkan kinen hakubutsukan shashin-shū [The Photo Collection of Late Viceroy Kodama and Former Chief Administrator Gotō Memorial Museum] (児玉総督後藤民政長官記念博物館写真集), Taipei: Takaishi Gumi, 1915

下載圖示
QR CODE