因許多人擁有齒列不正的問題且現今較為注重牙齒的美觀，因此矯正需求日漸上升。除原有的傳統矯正外，隱形矯正也因技術進步問世，隱形牙套在矯正期間能達到美觀的效果，造成越來越多人開始選擇配戴隱形牙套，除原本的研發者I牌外，在I牌隱形牙套專利過期後，開始有越來越多隱形牙套製造商選擇進入市場，其中最具特色的製造商為Z牌且其得以在市場龍頭底下存活。
本研究以單一個案分析並根據文獻探討及次級資料蒐集、對Z牌內部人員進行深度訪談，以此得知Z牌的資源活動、進入市場的方式及策略突圍，本研究顯示Z牌採取破壞式創新的方式進入市場，並在站穩腳步後，逐漸朝更大的市場邁進。除此之外，研究者也對 Z牌的Google評論進行主題分析、深度訪談牙醫師並加以編碼整理，以此了解市場對於Z牌破壞市場接受度。
由於隱形牙套市場上的其他競爭者無法穩定成長，Z牌的主要競爭對手為 I牌，因此研究者根據動態競爭的架構比較兩者的動態競爭行為，以此得知兩者間的攻擊及回應並了解結果的好壞。根據本研究的分析結果，研究者於最後整理出結論提出Z牌能和I牌競爭並存活的要素，並為Z牌提供後續於市場中的策略建議。

Due to the prevalence of malocclusion and growing emphasis on dental aesthetics nowadays, the demand for braces have risen. In addition to traditional braces, invisible braces also appear because of the advancement of technology. During the treatment, invisible braces are more aesthetic; therefore, more and more people choose to wear them. Since the patents of invisible braces held by I brand had expired, more invisible braces manufacturers entered the markets. Among the manufacturers, Z brand is the most unique and it exists under the market leader.
This research adopts case study approach with literature review, secondary data collection, and in-depth interviews with personnel of Z brand to know about its resources, activities, market entry strategy and strategic transformation. According to this research, Z brand entered the market through disruptive innovation and gradually expanded to larger target markets. Furthermore, the researcher conducted thematic analysis of Google reviews for Z brand and the interviews with dentist to clarify the acceptance of the market.
Given the instability of other competitors in the market, the main competitor of Z brand is I brand. This research introduces dynamic competition framework to compare the competitive behaviors of them. This analysis sheds light on their strategies of attacks and responses and the outcomes of the competitions. Based on these analyses, the research concludes by outlining the factors enabling Z brand to compete with I brand, why Z brand exists. Therefore, this research would provide strategic recommendations for continued success of Z brand.

司徒達賢 (2005)。策略管理新論-觀念架構與分析方法。 智勝文化。
行政院主計處 (2021)。行業統計分類。
行政院衛生署 (2004)。行政院衛生署所屬醫院自費醫療收費基準。
吳思華（2000)。策略九說：策略思考的本質，臺北：臉譜出版社。
李水蓮 (2023)。 用戶一年成長15倍 Zenyum綻雅台灣喜迎業績爆發年。 工商時報。 https://www.ctee.com.tw/news/20230117700713-431205
林熙 (2022)。2026年，隱形齒列矯正器市場估計將達到82 億美元。Genet 觀點。 http://www.genetinfo.com/international-news/item/35180.html
產業價值鏈資訊平台 (無日期)。醫療器材產業鏈簡介。2024年1月4日取自https://ic.tpex.org.tw/introduce.php?ic=C200
莊永明 (1998)。台灣醫療史：以臺大醫院為主軸。
陳明哲 (2010)。動態競爭。智勝文化。
陳明哲 (2013)。 間接競爭。2013年6月號-動盪定策略。https://www.hbrtaiwan.com/article/12311/indirect-competition
陳明哲 (2013)。「市場共同性－資源相似性」架構的應用。 2013年5月號-把創意變成好生意。 https://www.hbrtaiwan.com/article/12288/market-commonality-resource-similarity-framework
黃坤泰 (2000)。台灣牙醫執業的回顧。
葉哲政 (2014年4月29日)。全球牙科醫材市場分析與廠商經營動態分析。 ITIS產業評析。https://www.mirdc.org.tw/FileDownLoad/IndustryNews/2015211114648900.pdf
臺北市政府衛生局 (2020)。臺北市醫療機構牙科收費標準表。
蒔美牙醫集團 (無日期)。 隱適美如何收費？合理費用是多少？一篇瞭解隱適美價錢、隱適美流程。2024年4月21日取自https://www.smile-dental.tw/knowledgebase/id =14914
劉德明，陳操斐 (2009)。牙醫產業連鎖化經營策略之研究—兼論德邑與國維的營運模式。
劉潤 (2023)。商業簡史：看透商業進化，比別人先看到未來。時報出版。
衛生福利部 (2022)。醫療機構現況及醫院醫療服務量統計。
衛生福利部全民健康保險會 (2022)。全民健康保險醫療給付費用總額協商參考指標要覽。
錢怡雯 (2020年10月3日)。「牙齒矯正」流程介紹：為什麼不是第一次去就裝上矯正器？。關鍵評論網。https://www.thenewslens.com/article/140189
EDDY KUO (2023)。 十萬人都在做這件事，讓你脫下口罩更有自信！綻放品味細節從「微笑」開始！。 ELLE。https://www.elle.com/tw/life/hot-news/a45649989/zenyum-smile/
Mimi (2023)。 各家品牌搶進隱形牙套市場，矯正龍頭隱適美穩坐聲量龍頭，新加坡品牌綻雅推殺手級應用。 Qsearch。https://blog.qsearch.cc/2023/07/invisible-braces/
Zenyum (2021)。 牙套流程怎麼進行？一起瞭解Zenyum微笑旅程，我們將介紹整個過程。https://www.zenyum.com/tw-zh/blog/%E7%89%99%E5%A5%97%E6%B5%81%E7%A8%8B/
Zenyum (2022)。 隱形牙套不再是奢侈品！隱形牙套減低輕、中度齒列問題者荷包煩惱，更美觀也越來越流行。https://www.zenyum.com/tw-zh/blog/%E9%9A%B1%E5%BD%A2%E7%89%99%E5%A5%97%E5%A5%A2%E4%BE%88%E5%93%81/
ajaxdent (2022, June 10). Dental Unit. Medium. Retrieved from https://medium.com/@ajaxdent/dental-unit-428eca75f73
Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006).Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology.3(2),77-101.
Chapter 12 - Replicating Materials: Impression and Casting. (2019). In R. Sakaguchi, J. Ferracane, & J. Powers (Eds.), Craig's Restorative Dental Materials (Fourteenth Edition) (pp. 229-272). Philadelphia: Elsevier.
Christensen, C. M. (1997). The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail: Harvard Business Review Press.
Dorr, L. (2023, April 1). Understand the Differences Among Clear Aligner Materials. DENTAL PRODUCTS REPORT. Retrieved from https://www.dentalproductsreport.com/view/understand-the-differences-among-clear-aligner-materials
Eliades, T., Zinelis, S., Bourauel, C., & Eliades, G. (2010). Manufacturing of Orthodontic Brackets: A Review of Metallurgical Perspectives and Applications. Recent Patents on Materials Science, 1, 135-139. doi:10.2174/1874465610801020135
Feldbau, E. V., Frustino, J. L., & Migliorini, S. A. (2015). Chapter 8 - Restorative Dentistry. In S. T. Sonis (Ed.), Dental Secrets (Fourth Edition) (pp. 147-200). St. Louis: Elsevier.
Gale Encyclopedia of Nursing and Allied Health. Dental Instruments. Retrieved December 11, 2023 from Encyclopedia.com: https://www.encyclopedia.com/medicine/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/dental-instruments-0
J. White. (n.d.). How are Invisalign braces made?. Retrieved January 4, 2024 from Smiles by White: https://www.smilesbywhite.com/patient-information/news/how-are-invisalign-braces-made/
K. Tsukuma, S. Oda & H. Haga. (1988). T. Corp.
MICHAEL L. SWARTZ, D. (1988). Ceramic Brackets. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ORTHODONTIC. Retrieved from https://www.jco-online.com/archive/1988/02/82-ceramic-brackets/
Modern Dental Smiles Of Jupiter (2022, April 7). Dentures: Purpose, Components, Definition & Maintenance! Retrieved from https://medium.com/@moderndentalsmilesjupiter/dentures-purpose-components-definition-maintenance-477cbc06ab1d
MP Orthodontics. (2023, April 25). Ceramic Braces. Retrieved from https://www.mportho.com.au/advantages-of-clear-ceramic-braces/
Porter, M. E. (1979). How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy. Harvard Business Review.
Porter, M. E. (1985). Competitive Advantage.
Reinhardt, B., & Beikler, T. (2014). Chapter 4 - Dental Implants. In J. Z. Shen & T. Kosmač (Eds.), Advanced Ceramics for Dentistry (pp. 51-75). Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann
Smith, A. (1776). The Wealth of Nations.
Strauss, A & Corbin, J(1998). Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Sumita, M., Hanawa, T., Ohnishi, I., & Yoneyama, T. (2003). 9.04 - Failure Processes in Biometallic Materials. In I. Milne, R. O. Ritchie, & B. Karihaloo (Eds.), Comprehensive Structural Integrity (p. 131-167). Oxford: Pergamon.
Teh, S. J., & Lai, C. W. (2019). 5 - Carbon nanotubes for dental implants. In A. M. Asiri, Inamuddin, & A. Mohammad (Eds.), Applications of Nanocomposite Materials in Dentistry (pp. 93-105): Woodhead Publishing.
Y. Smith & B. Pharm (2023, January 18). Types of Dental Braces. News-Medical.Net. Retrieved from https://www.news-medical.net/health/Types-of-Dental-Braces.aspx
Zheng, L. W., Wang, J. Y., & Qing Yu, R. (2019). Biomaterials in Dentistry. In R. Narayan (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Biomedical Engineering (pp. 278-288). Oxford: Elsevier.